fbpx

The Ultimate Guide to Bathroom Tile Selection and Professional Installation in Indiana

Why Your Bathroom Tile Choices Matter More Than You Think

When you’re redoing a bathroom, tile might seem like just one more box to check. But the truth is, the tile you pick—and how it gets installed—can make or break the whole project.

We’ve seen bathrooms go from plain and basic to high-end and stylish with the right tile and a solid installation. Your tile choices don’t just affect how your bathroom looks. They impact how long it lasts, how easy it is to clean, and how safe it is to use every day.

Each area in the bathroom comes with different challenges. Shower walls need to handle constant moisture. Floors should help prevent slips. Wall tiles need to balance style with practicality.

And even if you pick the best tile on the market, it won’t matter if it’s installed the wrong way. We’ve torn out plenty of beautiful tiles ruined by bad installs—so yes, hiring someone who knows what they’re doing matters.

bathroom remodel

How to Choose Shower Tiles That Hold Up

Why Water Resistance Ratings Matter

In the shower, water resistance is non-negotiable. The best option? Tiles labeled “impervious,” which means they absorb less than 0.5% of water. These are built to handle daily soaking without breaking down over time.

Porcelain tiles usually offer the best water protection. Ceramic does a solid job too, especially outside the direct splash zone. Natural stone looks amazing, but you’ll need to seal it properly and keep up with maintenance. We always use a waterproof membrane and prep the surface correctly before any tile goes up. Without that, even the best tile will fail eventually.

What About Grout?

Grout doesn’t get enough attention, but it’s just as important as the tile itself. For showers, we recommend epoxy grout. It resists water, fights mold, and lasts way longer than basic cement grout. Yes, it costs more up front—but it saves you headaches later.

 

Why Bathroom Floor Tiles Need Special Attention

shower remodel

Safety First: Think Slip Resistance

Bathroom floors get wet—no surprise there. That’s why we always look at the slip resistance rating, called the COF (coefficient of friction). A COF of 0.42 or higher is the minimum for bathrooms, but we often aim for even better.

Smaller tiles (with more grout lines), matte finishes, and textured surfaces usually help prevent slipping. We guide clients toward options that don’t just look good—they help keep you safe.

Durability Counts

Bathroom floors take a beating—from foot traffic, dropped products, and cleaning. That’s why we often recommend porcelain. It’s dense, hard (7–9 on the Mohs scale), and resists damage well.

Natural stone looks stunning but needs careful selection for floors due to varying hardness. Lighter colors show less dirt and water spots, while darker ones can make a space feel cozier.

 

How to Pick Wall Tiles That Match Your Style

shower tiles

Tile Trends That Actually Work

Wall tiles are where you get to have fun. Subway tiles are always in style. Mosaic tiles add a pop of personality. And large format tiles give a clean, modern look with fewer grout lines.

White subway tile is popular for a reason—it’s timeless, affordable, and easy to pair with other materials. If you want something more unique, geometric patterns or textured tiles are great options.

Let Color Set the Mood

Color changes everything. Blues and greens feel spa-like. Whites and creams make the room feel bigger. Earth tones like beige or terracotta add warmth.

Pick a color you actually like, not just what’s trending. You’re the one who’ll see it every day, so go with what feels right.

Patterns and Details Matter

You can turn simple tiles into something special with patterns like herringbone or chevron. You don’t need fancy tiles—just a smart layout. We help clients choose layouts that match their bathroom size and style.

Accent tiles also make a big difference. A strip of mosaic in the shower or a tiled niche can become a focal point without blowing the budget.

 

The Pros and Cons of Each Bathroom Tile Material

bathroom remodel

Ceramic: Reliable and Budget-Friendly

Ceramic is easy to work with, affordable, and comes in tons of styles. It’s a great choice for walls or floors outside the shower. Just know it’s a little more fragile than porcelain.

Porcelain: Durable and Water-Resistant

Porcelain is top-of-the-line. It’s dense, water-resistant, and holds up to wear and tear. It costs more and is harder to cut, but it’s worth it if you want something that lasts.

Natural Stone: High-End Look, More Maintenance

Stone tiles—like marble, granite, or travertine—look amazing and feel luxurious. But they need sealing and extra care to keep them looking good. We mostly use them as accents or feature walls because of the upkeep.

 

Why Tile Size Changes Everything

shower tiles

How Size Affects the Look

Large tiles make a small bathroom feel bigger because there are fewer grout lines. Smaller tiles add texture and detail but can make a room feel busier.

What’s Harder to Install?

Smaller tiles often come in sheets, which helps with layout, but they still take finesse. Medium tiles (like 12x12s) are easier to install. Large tiles look sleek but need a flat surface and extra prep to avoid lippage (uneven edges). We use special tools to get them just right.

 

What You Need to Know About Tile Maintenance

Sealing and Cleaning Tips

  • Porcelain: No sealing needed. Just clean it regularly.
  • Ceramic: May need sealing in high-moisture areas.
  • Natural Stone: Needs sealing every 6–12 months.
  • Glass: Easy to clean, but grout still needs attention.

Polished tiles look clean but show water spots. Textured tiles hide spots but need more scrubbing.

Grout is the Hardest Part to Maintain

Dark grout hides stains but shows dust. Light grout looks bright but stains more easily. We always seal the grout lines to make cleaning easier and extend the life of the installation.

 

Why Professional Installation Really Matters

tile installer

Waterproofing Is Non-Negotiable

We never skip this step. A proper waterproof membrane behind your tile protects your home from serious damage. If it’s done wrong, water will find a way through—and the repair costs can be huge.

Checklist for Proper Waterproofing:
✓ Waterproof membrane
✓ Slope to drain
✓ Sealed edges around pipes
✓ Vapor barrier if needed
✓ Corner seals

Substrate Prep Makes the Difference

Tile needs a flat, stable surface. We fix any issues with the subfloor or walls before we even start tiling. That’s what keeps your tile from cracking, lifting, or falling apart over time.

Mistakes to Avoid

Bad waterproofing and poor layout are the two biggest mistakes we see. We plan tile layouts down to the inch so you don’t end up with tiny, awkward cuts or mismatched patterns.

 

How to Tie Everything Together

Coordinating Wall, Floor, and Shower Tiles

Not everything needs to match, but the tiles should feel like they belong together. A good rule of thumb is the 60-30-10 rule:

  • 60% main tile
  • 30% secondary tile
  • 10% accent tile

This gives balance without being boring.

Handling Transitions

Transitions between tile types (or from floor to wall) need to be clean. We use things like trim pieces or pencil tiles to make those transitions look polished and intentional.

 

What to Expect When Working With a Pro

Here’s how our process typically works:

  1. Consultation – We talk through your vision, budget, and options.
  2. Ordering Materials – We help you choose the right products.
  3. Prep Work – Demo, substrate fix, and waterproofing.
  4. Tile Install – Careful placement, leveling, and curing.
  5. Grout & Seal – Finish details and clean up.
  6. Final Walkthrough – We check everything together and go over maintenance.

Final Thoughts: Make Smart Tile Choices That Last

Your bathroom tile is more than just a design choice—it’s something you’ll live with every day. Pick materials that fit your style and lifestyle, and make sure they’re installed right the first time.

We help homeowners choose tiles that look great, last long, and perform well. Want to talk through your project? Reach out Artistic Tile & Design today for a consultation, and let’s build something beautiful that lasts.

Contact us today!
Scroll to Top